Why not use Google?

Classes started at AUC two weeks ago, but we’re just starting our first real session next week, in part because of an exemption exam and in part because of some construction delays on our new campus. In any case, as I prepare to teach two sections of our semester-long library class, I find myself wondering how I’ll convince students of the value of library resources.

Just today I’ve been doing some of my very own research, on canine seizures (a topic that, unfortunately, has become of great interest to me in the past few days). Right now I have an article printed out that I’ll read more carefully later. You know how I found it? This morning I googled dog seizures. I dismissed the first result. This article? It was the second result.

I did some evaluation almost unconsciously: I read through several paragraphs and took note of where it agreed with what little I already knew from my vet; considered its lack of currency (1995); noted the in-text citations; and glanced through the bibliography. But I did not research the article’s author, consult a library database, or even look at the URL.

So I did exactly what we tell our students not to do: google something and use one of the first few hits. Of course, I’m a librarian with a decent sense for what’s credible and what’s not. But I’m no expert in veterinary studies, and this article could be total bunk. But more than seeming credible, it answered all the questions I had, with an overview of the topic, explanation of symptoms and diagnoses, and a list of pharmaceutical and alternative treatments. In short, it gave me exactly what I wanted.

This week, if my students are feeling bold, they might ask me, “Why not Google?”

Ultimately, sometimes the most practical answer to this question may be, “Because your teacher says.”

How about you? What’s your best answer?

Advertisements

2 Responses

  1. Here’s another reason not to rely on the first Google hit:

    http://tinyurl.com/4r5apa

  2. I think you have to use google, because if you don’t, your students will view you as out of touch. (at least in the States, not sure about everywhere)

    So, I use google, and show them results for “credit cards college students” and “male pregnancy” and we talk about what is credible and what is not, and how you have to do MORE work with Google, because you have to double-check. But, with library databases, the checking has already been done.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: